Fish Bags - The Ultimate Buying Guide | Great Days Outdoors

Fish Bags – The Ultimate Buying Guide

When it comes to fishing, preserving the catch in optimal condition is vital for ensuring its freshness and taste. This is where fish bags play a crucial role, providing anglers with a reliable means of keeping their prized catches fresh throughout their journey from the water to the dinner table. In many scenarios, a fish bag offers a convenient way to prepare for the cold storage of fish without taking up as much space as a rigid fish cooler. That being said, with a plethora of fish bag options available on the market, finding the perfect one that suits individual needs can be a time-consuming task. This article will equip you with the knowledge and insights needed to make informed decisions.

Top Fish Bag Brands And Models

Calcutta Outdoors Pack Fish Cooler

Calcutta Outdoors Pack Fish Cooler


  • Easy pull-taped sealed zippers and secure clips keep everything compact and in place.
  • Welded waterproof inner liner keeps ice and water all on the inside.
  • Thick insulated no sweat design keeps fish fresh.
  • Strong woven nylon shoulder strap and carrying handles for convenient transport.

These coolers are expertly crafted to maintain the freshness of your catch, making them ideal for fishing trips. The bags are designed for easy carrying and transportation while delivering impressive performance. Additionally, measuring your catch becomes a breeze with the external built-in ruler. When not in use, you can conveniently fold them up for compact storage and transport. The pack fish cooler kill bags are constructed with seriously thick insulation, ensuring they are sturdy and hardworking.

AFTCO Insulated Fish Bag

AFTCO Insulated Fish Bag


  • Marine grade vinyl construction
  • ¾-inch closed cell foam
  • Inner aluminum foil
  • Zip-free rolldown style top
  • 1.5-inch nylon webbing with ¾-inch loops for securing to boat
  • Large nylon carrying straps
  • Inner liner is removable and easy to clean
  • Removable 1 ¾-inch drain with O-rings for a watertight seal

Harvesting fish requires swift cooling to preserve the valuable fillets. The AFTCO Insulated Fish Bag addresses common issues found in other bags. With a zipper-free design and compression straps, it effectively retains the cold. The removable inner liner is easy to clean, making maintenance hassle-free. Additionally, the bag features an oversized 1 ¾-inch opening for quick water and ice drainage. AFTCO also commits to a sustainable business model, which means integrating sustainability into their manufacturing processes, products, packaging, and day-to-day operations.

Buffalo Gear Insulated Fish Cooler Bag

Buffalo Gear


  • Keep ice-cold more than 24 hours
  • Heavy-duty heat-sealed, fiber-interlaced skin construction
  • Heavy-duty 22oz polyester Tarpaulin interior lining
  • Very thick walls
  • Strong strap
  • Drain plug

The Buffalo Gear kill bag preserves ice for multiple days as long as it is not exposed to direct sunlight. These bags are crafted using 22oz polyester Tarpaulin, providing exceptional leak-proof performance. The welded construction, with no sewing, prevents blood and slime from soaking through and keeps your boat clean. Moreover, the bag features a double-layer of one-of-a-kind, 1/2 inch thick, Close-cell foam insulation, ensuring that your fish stay cold for extended periods.

Fish Kill Bags Insulated Fish Cooler Bag

Fish Kill Bags Insulated cooler


  • 70 quart capacity
  • 55C PVC tarpaulin inner material
  • NBR rubber outer material
  • 100% airtight, puncture resistant, long lasting
  • 100% RF welded seams
  • 304 grade stainless steel zipper head & other fittings
  • Removable shoulder straps & 4x RF welded handles for easy carrying
  • Large & heavy duty threaded rubber gasket plug

The Fish Bags’ kill bag is a convenient way to transport your catch from the pond to the ice chest. It features a quick-release buckle for easy handling and comes in three sizes with a dual zipper sealing & leakproof design. The breathable mesh inner lining prevents odors and moisture buildup.


Elkton Outdoors Insulated Fish Cooler Bag

Elkton Outdoors Insulated Fish Cooler Bag


  • Double wall premium insulation
  • Non-stick interior lining
  • 3-point folding system for easy storage
  • 4 carry handles and a removable shoulder strap
  • 3-nozzle boomless boom delivers 30 ft. of spray coverage
  • Easy-grip zipper
  • Reinforced heat welded seams 

The Elkton insulated fish outdoor cooler bag has double wall premium insulation and leak-proof performance, it maintains freshness even after long fishing trips. Available in 40” x 20” and 60” x 20” sizes, the bag’s 3-point folding system allows easy storage in kayaks or fishing boats. The non-stick interior lining aids in cleaning up, simply rinse and towel dry. Four carry handles and a removable shoulder strap provide easy carrying, and the rugged design with puncture-resistant materials ensures durability for years to come.

Reliable Fishing Products Insulate Fish Cooler Bag

Reliable Fishing Products Insulate Fish Cooler Bag


  • Approximately 85 quarts
  • Heavy-duty 18 oz. vinyl coated polyester
  • UV- and mildew-resistant thread
  • 0.5″ dense, closed-cell foam
  • Drain plug
  • Non-corrosive YKK zipper
  • 12″ Gusseted bottom sits flat, expands for larger capacity

Reliable Fishing Products insulated fish bags offers UV and mildew resistance, ensuring your catch remains fresh regardless of the weather conditions. The closed cell foam technology guarantees ice retention for as long as required, keeping your fish cold, fresh, and safe even on scorching days. Moreover, the convenient drain plug located at the bottom corner allows for easy cleaning, rinsing, and draining of your fish after use.

Smith’s Insulated Fish Kill Bag

Smith's Insulated Fish Kill Bag


  • Gusseted flat bottom
  • Approximately 130 quarts
  • Features heavy-duty washable marine grade Tarpaulin inside and out
  • Non-corrosive zipper with pulls and two rear tie down loops.
  • Two sets of center padded handles with two large end handles for up to four-person carry when fully loaded.
  • Drain plug allows you to rinse and clean your catch

Introducing Smith’s Insulated Fish Kill Bag – the perfect solution for preserving your catch’s freshness. With its premium insulation, leak-proof design, and durable construction, this bag ensures your fish remain cool and secure throughout your fishing adventures. Easy to clean and equipped with convenient carrying handles, Smith’s Insulated Fish Kill Bag is a must-have for every angler.

Understanding Fish Bags

What are fish bags and how do they differ from regular coolers or containers?

Fish bags are specialized containers designed to preserve the freshness and quality of freshly caught fish during transportation from the fishing location to the final destination. Unlike regular coolers or containers, fish bags are specifically engineered to be folded flat to help with storage or placement on small boats and kayaks where a large, rigid fish cooler takes up too much space.

  1. Insulation and Temperature Control: One of the most significant distinctions between fish bags and regular coolers is their insulation capabilities. Fish bags are typically crafted with high-quality materials and advanced insulation techniques that effectively retain the desired temperature inside the bag. Maintaining the right temperature is essential to prevent the fish from spoiling, as it slows down bacterial growth and enzymatic reactions responsible for the fish’s deterioration.
  2. Water Resistance and Leakproof Design: Fish bags are designed with waterproof and leakproof features to prevent water from entering or escaping the bag. This is particularly important because freshly caught fish are often wet and can release liquids during transportation. The waterproofing in fish bags not only protects the catch from external water but also ensures that any liquids released by the fish are contained within the bag, preventing spills and maintaining the hygiene of the surrounding environment.
  3. Portability and Storage: Fish bags are often designed with portability and storage in mind. Many fish bags come with sturdy handles, shoulder straps, or even backpack-style carrying options to facilitate comfortable and hassle-free movement. This portability makes fish bags ideal for anglers, such as beach kayak anglers, who may need to traverse long distances to reach their fishing spot. They are also ideal for boats where the possibility of catching fish that are larger than the boat’s fish box is possible.

These features make fish bags the ultimate choice for anglers and fishermen seeking to maintain the freshness and quality of their catch, ensuring that the journey from the waters to the table is both efficient and delicious.


Importance of temperature control and insulation in fish bags

Temperature control and insulation are crucial elements in fish bags that play a pivotal role in preserving the quality and freshness of the catch during transportation. Fish are highly perishable and sensitive to temperature changes, making it essential to maintain a consistent and cool environment inside the fish bag. Effective insulation helps slow down the enzymatic reactions and bacterial growth that lead to spoilage, thereby extending the shelf life of the fish and ensuring it remains safe for consumption. By controlling the temperature and preventing the fish from being exposed to external heat sources, such as sunlight or warm air, fish bags with proper insulation significantly reduce the risk of bacterial proliferation and foodborne illnesses. 

Temperature control and insulation in fish bags are vital for minimizing food waste, maximizing the quality of the catch. (Photo courtesy of AFTCO)

Additionally, maintaining the right temperature within the fish bag allows anglers and fishermen to extend their fishing trips without the worry of the catch going bad quickly. Whether for recreational anglers or commercial fishermen, temperature control and insulation in fish bags are vital for minimizing food waste, maximizing the quality of the catch, and ultimately ensuring that the seafood reaches the table in its freshest and most delectable state.

Factors To Consider When Buying Fish Bags

Fish Bag Size And Capacity

Selecting the right size and capacity for a fish bag is crucial to ensure that it can accommodate the catch comfortably and maintain its freshness during transportation. When choosing a fish bag, anglers should consider the types of fish they typically catch and the average size of their catches. A bag that is too small may lead to overcrowding, bruising, and reduced airflow, potentially compromising the quality of the fish. On the other hand, an excessively large fish bag might result in unnecessary extra space that can affect insulation and temperature control. Moreover, the size should also align with the angler’s fishing style and the duration of their fishing trips. For short outings or smaller catches, a compact fish bag might suffice, while extended trips or larger catches may require a more spacious option. It is essential to strike the right balance between size and capacity to ensure that the fish bag provides enough room for the catch to lie comfortably without compromising its insulation capabilities.

Fish Bag Material And Durability

The choice of fish bag material and its durability is paramount to ensuring the longevity and effectiveness of the container in preserving the catch. Fish bags are commonly constructed using a variety of materials, such as vinyl, PVC, insulated fabric, or heavy-duty nylon. Each material offers distinct advantages concerning insulation, water resistance, and overall sturdiness. Vinyl and PVC are popular choices for their waterproof properties, making them highly effective in containing any liquids released by the fish and preventing leaks during transportation. Insulated fabric fish bags provide excellent temperature control, keeping the catch cool and fresh for extended periods. Heavy-duty nylon materials are known for their durability and resistance to wear and tear, ensuring the fish bag can withstand the rugged conditions often encountered during fishing trips.

Durability is a critical factor in fish bags, as anglers require a container that can endure the demands of frequent use and exposure to the elements. Reinforced seams and sturdy zippers contribute to the bag’s durability, preventing tears or breakages when handling heavy loads of fish. Additionally, materials that are resistant to UV rays and abrasions further enhance the bag’s longevity. Anglers should choose fish bags made from high-quality materials that strike the right balance between weight and robustness, ensuring the bag can withstand the rigors of fishing excursions while maintaining its ability to effectively insulate and protect the catch. Investing in a durable fish bag ensures that anglers can rely on its performance throughout various fishing trips, guaranteeing their catches remain in optimal condition until they reach the shore or kitchen.

Insulation And Cooling Technology In Fish Bags

When purchasing a fish bag, careful consideration of insulation and cooling technology is essential to ensure that the catch remains fresh and safe for consumption. Insulation plays a critical role in maintaining the desired temperature inside the fish bag, preventing rapid spoilage and bacterial growth. Advanced insulation materials, such as closed-cell foam or high-quality thermal barriers, provide effective temperature control, keeping the interior cool and preventing heat from entering the bag.

Fish Bag Portability And Carrying Options For Fish Bags

Fish bag portability and the availability of various carrying options are crucial considerations when choosing the right fish bag for fishing adventures. Anglers often need to move around frequently, whether on a boat, kayak, or on foot, to find the best fishing spots. Therefore, a portable fish bag that is easy to carry becomes an invaluable asset. Many fish bags come equipped with sturdy handles, allowing anglers to carry them by hand with ease. Some models feature convenient shoulder straps, enabling hands-free transportation, which is particularly useful when navigating uneven terrain or hiking to remote fishing locations.

man getting on boat
Heavy duty carry straps make carrying you catch off the boat much easier. (Photo courtesy of Calcutta)

For anglers who require even more mobility, fish bags with backpack-style carrying options are available, evenly distributing the weight for enhanced comfort during extended trips.

Waterproof And Leakproof Features In Fish Bags

Waterproof and leakproof features in fish bags are vital aspects that ensure the catch remains protected and the surrounding environment stays clean and dry. Fish bags are designed to handle wet and slippery conditions, and the inclusion of waterproof materials and leakproof seals prevents water from entering or escaping the bag during transportation. This not only safeguards the fish from external moisture but also contains any liquids released by the catch, avoiding spills and potential contamination.

The waterproof and leakproof characteristics of fish bags are especially crucial for preserving the freshness and quality of the catch. They prevent water from seeping into the bag, which could lead to a loss of temperature control and compromise the fish’s condition. Additionally, the leakproof design ensures that unpleasant odors and potential bacterial growth are contained within the bag, maintaining a hygienic and odor-free fishing environment.

Fish Bag Maintenance And Care Tips

Cleaning and sanitizing fish bags for hygienic use

Cleaning and sanitizing fish bags are essential steps in maintaining their hygienic use and ensuring the safety of the catch. After each fishing trip, it is crucial to thoroughly clean the fish bag to remove any remnants of fish, blood, or other debris. Start by rinsing the bag with freshwater to wash away visible dirt. Next, use a mixture of mild soap and water to scrub the interior and exterior of the bag, paying close attention to seams and corners where residues might accumulate.

For tougher stains or odors, consider using a mixture of water and vinegar or baking soda, which are natural deodorizers and disinfectants. Rinse the bag thoroughly with clean water to eliminate any soap or cleaning agents. Once the bag is clean, it is important to sanitize it to kill any remaining bacteria or pathogens. You can use a solution of water and bleach or a commercial disinfectant, following the manufacturer’s instructions for dilution and contact time. After sanitization, ensure the bag is completely dry before storing it. Properly cleaning and sanitizing fish bags after each use not only keeps them in top condition but also prevents the buildup of harmful bacteria, ensuring that future catches remain safe and uncontaminated during transportation and storage.

Proper storage and maintenance to prolong the life of fish bags

Proper storage and maintenance are crucial practices to prolong the life of fish bags and ensure their continued effectiveness in preserving catches. After each fishing trip, it is essential to clean and sanitize the fish bag, as mentioned earlier, to remove any residual fish matter and prevent bacterial growth. Once the bag is completely dry, store it in a cool and dry location away from direct sunlight and extreme temperatures. Avoid storing the fish bag in areas with excessive humidity, as this can lead to mold and mildew growth. If the fish bag is collapsible, fold it neatly to avoid unnecessary stress on seams and zippers.

fish bag
An insulated fish bag takes up less room on your boat than a standard cooler. (Photo courtesy of Buffalo Gear)

Regularly inspect the bag for any signs of wear, tear, or damage, such as frayed seams or compromised insulation. Promptly address any issues by repairing or replacing damaged components to prevent further deterioration. Additionally, avoid overloading the fish bag with excessively heavy catches beyond its capacity, as this can strain the bag and reduce its longevity.

Final Thoughts On Fish Bags

We hope that this guide serves as a comprehensive resource for anglers and fishermen seeking the perfect fish bag to preserve their catches and enhance their fishing experiences. Considering factors such as size and capacity based on fishing needs, storage limitations, and transportation requirements ensures that the chosen fish bag aligns perfectly with individual preferences and fishing styles. If you focus on quality, a fish bag should be a purchase that will last you for many, many years to come.

Full Disclosure: This post may include affiliate links. There’s no extra charge to our readers for using these.

Stay Updated

Get outdoor trends, data, new products, and tips delivered to your inbox.