Choosing the Best Broadheads for Deer Hunting | Great Days Outdoors

Choosing the Best Broadheads for Deer Hunting

Choosing the best broadheads for deer hunting can seem like a daunting task. With dozens of products on the market, selecting the right one can be difficult. It’s a process, though, and there are things to consider, including budget, broadhead type, weapon type, arrow setup, and more. It’s all about determining your needs. Here are eight factors to keep in mind when choosing the best broadheads for deer hunting.

 

1. Broadhead Type

There are multiple categories, or types, of broadheads. The first is the fixed blade, which many people refer to as “cut-on-contact” heads. Structurally, these are sounder, and tend to be more durable. Some of these are also much easier to sharpen and have easily changable replacement blades. These do have downsides. Fixed-blade heads are smaller in diameter. These also tend to be slightly less accurate, especially if the bow isn’t tuned.

ADVERTISEMENT / ADVERTISE WITH US

 

Also referred to as “expandables”, mechanical broadheads are next in line. These are kings of accuracy and tend to fly very well. Another benefit is much larger cutting diameters, with some broadheads nearing three inches across. Again, there are downsides, though. These heads tend to get decreased penetration. There is also higher risk of malfunction, including failed deployments, deflections upon impact, etc.

Lastly, there are hybrids, which are the newest broadhead inventions and offer the best of the fixed-blade and mechanical broadhead worlds. Generally, these have two expandable blades, but also have two small fixed blades. The latter are usually called “bleeders” and are cut-on-contact slivers of death.

 

2. Animal Size

Once you understand the differences in broadhead types, it’s important to assess the type of hunting you plan to do. Small to medium-sized game, such as whitetails, are clear for any of the three broadhead types. That said, larger animals,  such as elk and moose,  have thicker hides, denser muscles, and bigger bones. Those planning to hunt larger game oftentimes see better penetration with fixed blades. Those with an archery setup that has higher kinetic energy output might still do well with a mechanical head.

ADVERTISEMENT / ADVERTISE WITH US

 

3. Weapon Setup

The next consideration is the weapon setup. Kinetic energy is everything, and higher levels of it improve overall penetration. Crossbows and compound bows with higher draw weights, longer draw lengths, and greater speeds, produce more energy which is transferred to the shaft and broadhead.

 

4. Broadhead Weight

Broadheads range in size from 75 to 200 grains. Light weights fly faster but  a heavier broadhead improves the amount of kinetic energy transferred during the shot process. Selecting an option that’s 125 grains or greater tends to increase penetration depth. Fortunately, this year, there are numerous options that are 125-200 grains.

 

5. Arrow Setup

A heavier arrow also boosts kinetic energy. Paired with a faster bow and heavier broadhead, this can be a deadly setup. Syncing the broadhead selection to your arrow is an important consideration.

 

6. Cutting Diameter

Some broadheads have smaller cutting diameters. Others have much wider cutting surfaces. While shorter diameters are typically confined to fixed blades, the latter can make the difference with subpar shot opportunities.

 

7. Product Materials

All broadheads aren’t created equally. Some are crafted from one material, while others include a mix. Choosing a strong metal, such as titanium, can increase the longevity of the broadhead.

 

8. Your Budget

Lastly, analyze your budget and make a choice that best fits your needs. It’s always good practice to purchase the best you can afford. Because, choosing the best broadhead for deer hunting is somewhat subjective. Only you can determine which broadhead will be right for your hunting situation.

 

5 Best Fixed-Blade Broadheads for Deer

MODEL: G5 M3 Muzzy One Iron Will Single Bevel Magnus Stinger Buzzcut Wasp Sharpshooter 200
CUTTING DIAMETER: 1.0625" 1 1/8" (100 grain) / 1 1/4" (125 grain) 1 1/16" (main blade) / 3/4" (bleeder blade) 1 1/16" 1"
CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL: 420 high-grade stainless steel Machined stainless-steel ferrule Hardened ferrules (cryogenically treated and triple tempered to 60 HRC hardness) Varies Steel
WEIGHT: 100 or 125 grain 85, 100, or 125 grain 100-250 grains 85, 100, 125, or 150 grain 200 grain
PRICING: CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE

 

5 Best Mechanical Broadheads for Deer

Best Broadheads for Deer Best Broadheads for Deer Best Broadheads for Deer Best Broadheads for Deer Best Broadheads for Deer
MODEL: G5 MegaMeat NAP KillZone Max Wasp Jak-Hammer Grim Reaper Razorcut NAP Endgame
CUTTING DIAMETER: 2" 2 3/8" 1 1/4" 1 3/8", 1 3/4", or 2" 1 3/16"
CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL: Steel Steel Stainless steel Stainless steel Titanium / Stainless steel
WEIGHT: 100 or 125 grain 100 grain 75 or 100 grain 85, 100, or 125 grain 100 grain
PRICING: CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE

 

5 Best Hybrid Broadheads for Deer

Best Broadheads for Deer Best Broadheads for Deer Best Broadheads for Deer Best Broadheads for Deer
MODEL: Ramcat Diamondback Hybrid Muzzy Trocar HB Hybrid 4-Blade Slick Trick Assailant NAP DK4 Grim Reaper Pro Micro Hybrid
CUTTING DIAMETER: 2" 1 5/8" 1 3/4" 1 3/4" 1 1/4", 1 3/8", or 1 3/4"
CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL: Stainless steel Stainless steel Stain steel Steel Stainless steel
WEIGHT: 100 grain 100 grain 100 grain 100 or 125 grain 100 or 125 grain
PRICING: CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE

 

5 Best Crossbow Broadheads for Deer

Best Broadheads for Deer Best Broadheads for Deer Best Broadheads for Deer Best Broadheads for Deer
MODEL: Raven Steel SEVR Titanium 2.0 Annihilator 100 XL Dead Ringer Super Freak Extreme Rage Hypodermic Crossbow NC
CUTTING DIAMETER: 2" 2" 1 1/16" 2 3/4" 2"
CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL: 416 steel Titanium 4140 alloy steel (hardened to Rockwell RC: 52 with 30-degree beveled edges) Unknown Stainless steel
WEIGHT: 100 grain 100 or 125 grain 100 grains 100 grain 100 or 125 grain
PRICING: CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE CHECK PRICE

 

The Best Overall Broadhead for Deer

Overall, the best deer hunting broadhead will vary from person to person. It’s all about selecting the right one for your specific need. That’s why there are so many options on the market. Each one caters to a slightly different set of lists and needs. It’s up to you to sift through the offerings and choose accordingly. Of course, if you hit a deer perfectly, it really doesn’t matter the brand or model of the pointy tip on your arrows. Still, choosing the best broadhead for deer hunting is a very real thing. Take it seriously this season.


Disclosure: There are some affiliate links above. These are all products we highly recommend. We would not put anything on this page that we haven’t verified.

Stay Updated

Get outdoor trends, data, new products, and tips delivered to your inbox.